Can businesses foster genuine community-building when the engagement feels forced?

Starbucks, the coffee giant known for its personalised touch and community-driven ethos, has once again found itself in the spotlight.

This time, it's about their reintroduction of handwritten "positive messages" on cups. Intended to create a sense of connection and community, the initiative has sparked a lively debate.

Is this a genuine effort to engage customers, or is it merely forced community-building?

For many years, Starbucks has been celebrated for its ability to make each customer feel unique. The simple act of a barista calling your name as they hand over your cup is more than just customer service; it’s a core part of the brand’s identity. Personalisation, such as writing names on cups, has helped Starbucks build a sense of community. 

However, there’s a fine line between authentic engagement and what might now feel like a corporate mandate.

Recently, Starbucks has taken this personalisation one step further by requiring baristas to write positive messages on customers' cups. Phrases such as "You’ve got this!" and "Stay positive!" are being added to cups as part of an effort to spread a little joy. But here's the catch: this isn’t a voluntary gesture; it’s now a company directive. 

Baristas are obliged to write these messages, regardless of how they feel about it. While the goal is to foster a positive, community-minded atmosphere, the practice has proven to be more controversial than anticipated.

At first glance, this initiative seems like a thoughtful gesture. Who doesn’t appreciate a little positivity? 

However, for some, the forced nature of the act has sparked concern. The initiative may be intended to deepen connections with customers, but when baristas are compelled to write these messages without genuine enthusiasm, it raises the question of whether these interactions can still be considered authentic.

Many baristas have voiced their frustrations, feeling that this directive compromises their ability to engage with customers in a way that feels true to them. The idea of writing positive messages on cups might have been well-received when it was voluntary, but now that it’s mandated, it risks losing its charm. 

The question arises: Can businesses foster genuine community-building when the engagement feels forced?

This latest move by Starbucks raises broader questions about the role of businesses in building communities. Starbucks has long prided itself on creating "third places"—spaces where customers feel at home and connected. 

The idea behind the positive cup messages is to enhance this sense of belonging and encourage a more supportive, uplifting environment.

But when a company starts imposing these kinds of initiatives on its employees, it risks undermining the very sense of authenticity that made engagement so effective in the first place. Engagement is most powerful when it’s genuine, not scripted. 

One of the core elements of community-building is trust—something that can quickly be lost if customers or employees feel that they are being manipulated.

From a customer’s perspective, receiving a handwritten message on a cup might initially seem like a lovely touch. It’s a simple way for a business to show that it cares. However, the customer experience is defined by authenticity. If these positive messages start to feel like a corporate gimmick, they could have the opposite effect. Instead of making customers feel more connected, they might feel like the personal touch is no longer sincere.

This is a pivotal moment for Starbucks. The company must ask itself whether such initiatives genuinely help build community or simply serve as an attempt to manufacture connection. True community-building requires authenticity, and sometimes the best connections happen when people are allowed to be themselves, without corporate pressure.

Starbucks’ decision to reintroduce positive cup messages offers an important insight into the challenges of modern customer engagement. While the idea of creating positivity and connection through simple gestures may seem like a win, the reality is that authenticity is key. Forced interactions rarely result in lasting, meaningful engagement.

At the end of the day, Starbucks must find a way to balance its community-focused values with real, human connections. 

The future of engagement lies in sincerity, where both customers and employees feel truly seen and heard—not just when it’s part of a company mandate.

‍